Posts

A Complaint claiming Rs.40 lakhs alleging that Complainant was not informed of the diagnosis, dismissed.

"The mere fact that a patient dies in a hospital does not lead to the presumption that the death occurred due to the negligence of the doctor and in order to make a doctor criminally responsible for death of his patient." Case Details : Mohd. Kasur Parvez V/s. St. Stephen's Hospital, Delhi. Compliant No.87/2008, decided on 19/03/2018, By Hon. Delhi State Commission, Before : HON’BLE  SH. O.P. GUPTA, MEMBER(JUDICIAL), HON’BLE  SH. ANIL SRIVASTAVA, MEMBER Judgment Link : http://cms.nic.in/ncdrcusersWeb/GetJudgement.do?method=GetJudgement&caseidin=8%2F0%2FCC%2F08%2F87&dtofhearing=2018-03-13 Facts in Short. 1.The case goes back to 2007. The Complainant filed the complaint claiming Rs.40 Lakhs against the Hospital on the ground of death of his wife. 2. It was alleged that complainant’s wife Smt. Zaheda Rajat Quraisee,  a teacher in the Department of Human Resources Development of Bihar Govt. was admitted to the Hospital as she was having seve...

Doctors, Shop (Act) is closed till further order.

Doctors, Shop (Act) is closed till further order !! The Hon. Bombay High Court previously had observed : “Professional Establishment of a Doctor does not come under the definition of “Commercial Establishment” unless the Activity carried on is commercial in nature. Difference between professional activity and commercial activity is that professional activity is carried on by an individual by his personal skill while commercial activity is systematically and habitually undertaken for production of goods or rendering services to the Community”. The Doctors which were pulled out from the canopy of Shop Act, have been again brought under the 4 corners of said Act ? The recent Bill L.A. Bill No. LIV 0f 2017, introduced in Maha. Legislative Assembly on 08th August, 2017 has categorically 'admitted' Doctors, Hospitals, dispensary, clinic, polyclinic, maternity home in the definition of term 'establishment' under the said Act. They were not specifically included in...

Out of Rs.1 Crore, Rs.75 lakhs were claimed towards mental pain and agony.. Well, the case got dismissed. The patient was also found to be in good health.

Can any one suffer mental pain & agony of Rs.75 lakhs ? !! - The unrealistic case filed just to confer jurisdiction directly on NCDRC, got dismissed. Case Details. Reetu Jhamat V/s. M/s. Neelkanth Hospital, Gurgaon, & 2 others. CC No.2661/2017. Decided on 15/05/2018. Before : HON'BLE MR. DR. B.C. GUPTA,PRESIDING MEMBER.   HON'BLE MR. DR. S.M. KANTIKAR,MEMBER. Judgment Link : http://cms.nic.in/ncdrcusersWeb/GetJudgement.do?method=GetJudgement&caseidin=0%2F0%2FCC%2F2661%2F2017&dtofhearing=2018-05-15 Facts in short : 1.The Complainant was having abdominal pain, on 03.08.2016 approached Dr. Subrat Saxena i.e. the Opponent No.2 in the said Hospital. After USG she was diagnosed with “Cholelithiassis” i.e. Gall bladder stone (multiple small gall bladder stone). 2. She underwent laparoscopic Cholecystectomy on the same day and discharged from the hospital on 5.8.2016. However she had severe abdominal pain, she was again hospital on 07.0...

The conduct of a Treating Doctor Conduct fell below that of a reasonably competent doctor, Rs.4.75 lakhs saddled as compensation.

ERCP preferred over MRCP - Landed Doctors in trouble.. Case Details : M/s. St. Stephen’s Hospital,  Delhi. V/s.  Masood Zafar Case No. F.A.No.65/2006, Decided on 08/05/2018 Before : N P KAUSHIK (Member - Judicial) Link : http://cms.nic.in/ncdrcusersWeb/GetJudgement.do?method=GetJudgement&caseidin=8%2F0%2FFA%2F65%2F2006&dtofhearing=2018-05-08 Facts in Short : 1. The case goes back to January-2000. The Respondent-Complainant Mr. Zafar took his ailing mother to the Appellant Hospital as she was suffering from severe headache. However the MRI Scan did not show any abnormality. After 4 days, she was again hospitalized for severe abdominal pain. 2. A tentative diagnosis of cholecystitis (gall bladder disease) was made.  Ultrasound revealed biliary sludge with mild biliary dilation and showed a stone in the common bile duct. As per the advise of Dr. Lahoti, the Gastroenterologist  ERCP procedure were performed on 24.01.2000. But th...

Under-Staffing of Nurses and Doctors in the Hospital, amounts to deficiency & made the Hospital to pay Rs.2 lakhs.

Allegations of Medical Negligence were turned down, but Hospital was held liable to pay Rs. 2 lakhs (reduced from Rs.15 lakhs, though) for having  inadequate staff and Doctors   Case Details : Indraprastha Medical Corp. Ltd., Sarita Viahr, New Delhi. V/s. Rajiv Gandotra & United India Insurance Co. Ltd.        First Appeal NO.220/2008, D.O.J. - 15/05/2018. Before : Dr. S.M. Kantikar - Member. Judgment Link : http://cms.nic.in/ncdrcusersWeb/GetJudgement.do?method=GetJudgement&caseidin=0%2F0%2FFA%2F220%2F2008&dtofhearing=2018-05-15 Facts in short : 1. The Hospital filed the appeal against the Order of State Commission which directed the Insurance Co. to pay Rs.5 lakh and further directed the Hospital to pay total Rs.10 lakhs towards punitive damages to the Opponent No.1 - the Complainant, 2. The complainant, Rajiv Gandotra’s wife, Vandana ( ‘the patient’) was admitted in Opponent No-1-Apollo Hospital at Sarita Viha...

An Interesting case : Court dismissed a case of Rs.6 Cr.+, as the patient whose eyesight allegedly damaged, found to be active on Social media. Adv. ROHiT Erande. ©

A patient who alleged that his eyesight was severely damaged and his life was ruined, was found by Doctors to be active on social media.  At last, Highly inflated claim of Rs.6 Crore+ dismissed.  Great efforts were taken by doctors to find out the truth..  Mind well Social-Media is a two edged sword... Case Details : Saurabh Saini V/s. New Delhi Center For Sight Pvt. Ltd. & others. Consumer Case No.70/2016 decided on 10/05/2018. Before : Hon.Dr. S.M. Kantikar, Member. Link : http://cms.nic.in/ncdrcusersWeb/GetJudgement.do?method=GetJudgement&caseidin=0%2F0%2FCC%2F70%2F2016&dtofhearing=2018-05-10 Facts in short : 1. The Complainant underwent Torik Implantable Collamer Lens (TICL) due to his high myopic status & thin cornea. It was alleged that there were many lapses in performing TICL.  The Allegations may be arrayed as under : a) The surgery was unsuccessful.   b) The  behaviour  doctors was bad and...

Rs. 5 Crore case dismissed as Doctors followed the Standard Protocols of Treatment.

 A case claiming Rs. 5 Crores (!) dismissed, as Doctors followed the Standard Protocols of Treatment.  Case Details : Abdul Shaik V/s.Dr. Vikram Mathews, Christian Medial College, TN. CC No.194/2009. Before : Dr. S.M.Kantikar (presiding Member) Judgment Link : http://cms.nic.in/ncdrcusersWeb/GetJudgement.do?method=GetJudgement&caseidin=0%2F0%2FCC%2F194%2F2009&dtofhearing=2018-03-19 Facts in short : 1. Mulla Abdul, the patient, was admitted to Christian Medical College (CMC) in June-2007 for further management of  Mylodisplastic Syndrome (MDS) from Vellore. It was alleged that without concrete diagnosis, the patient was shifted to Cancer ward and was put under heavy treatment of powerful injections and it lea to serious side effects like swelling of his both legs, below waist, both ankles and in both wrists. However there was no treatment given. 2. The Doctors could not diagnosis and suspected TB also. His sputum sa...