Posts

"Save Doctors to Save yourselves..." Beat the wrong mindset, not the Doctors"

"Save Doctors to Save yourselves..." Beat the wrong mindset, not the Doctors" Adv. Rohit Erande. © If Doctors cannot be treated as God's,they cannot be condemned as Devils too.. In these  days of Corona Pandemic, Doctors are risking thier lives to save us, but sorry to  say that some people are  not mature enough to treat the doctors. The Following message is loud and clear : At all other places : If you are sneezing, having cold, fever, then don't come to us.. But.... In Hospitals, Drs. And Nursing Staff : If you are sneezing, having cold, fever, then please come to us immediately..  In last week a pediatrician in Bolthan, Nashik Dist, Maharashtra was beaten to 12 stitches. Yesterday a Doctor in Malegaon Dist, Maharashtra, was reportedly beaten as he dis not answer phone of MLA... Attacks on Doctors have become very common that sarcastically, any one can get a Doctorate in this subject.. It is said that there is unity in diversity in...

A Doctor is not expected to work like a machine or a computer; He is also a human being".."

"A doctor cannot give complete assurance and guarantee to save life of a patient.   " Adv. ROHiT ERANDE.© Case Details : Charan Kamal Chopra V/s. Dr. R.K. Gupta, Haryana & anr. Rev. Pet. No. 1942/2018. Before : Hon  Dr. S.M. Kantikar - Presiding Member &  Hon. Mr. Dinesh Singh, Member Decided on : 18/04/2019 Judgment Link  http://cms.nic.in/ncdrcusersWeb/GetJudgement.do?method=GetJudgement&caseidin=0%2F0%2FRP%2F1942%2F2018&dtofhearing=2019-04-18 Facts in short : 1. The Complainant's mother 78 yrs of age, the patient in this case, was admitted in the Hospital in ICCU. All the tests like ECH, Echo, , Blood tests, USG etc. were perfomred. 2. The patient was a known patient of High BP and Diabetics for nearly 15 years. Her blood urea was 152% mg and Serum Creatinie was 8.2% mg, which was much more than the normal range. 3. Thus as it was a case of renal failure, as a standard protocol she was advised hemodialysis....

Careless Laser Eye Surgery : Rs.50 lakhs saddled upon Eye hospital.

Case Details : MS. PRASANNA LAKSHMI V/s. MAXIVISION LASER CENTER PVT. LTD., Hyderabad Decided on 05/04/2019 by Hon. National Commission Before :  HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE R.K. AGRAWAL,PRESIDENT and  Mrs. M. Shreesha, Member Judgment Link : http://cms.nic.in/ncdrcusersWeb/GetJudgement.do?method=GetJudgement&caseidin=0%2F0%2FFA%2F196%2F2013&dtofhearing=2019-04-05 Facts in brief : Both the parties have approached to national commission against the Judgment and Order passed by the Andhra Pradesh State Commission, Complainant  for enhancement of compensation and Hospital for dismissal of Complaint. 1.The Complainant - Petitioner-in-person was suffering from short sight problems and hence was approached to the Respondent Hospital. It is to be noted that complainant and her family members used to go same hospital whenever they had eye problems.  2. It is averred that one Dr. Ravi Shanker of the Lasik Centre suggested Lasik Surgery for the...

Abortion after 20 weeks is now permitted. Hon. Bombay High Court in its landmark judgment has given great relief to needy Mothers and Doctors too..

Case Details : XYZ V/s. State of Maharashtra (W.P. No.10835/2018) along with other petitions Decided by Division Bench of Hon. Bombay High Court, 03/04/2019 CORAM : Hon. Abhay S. Oka & Hon. M.S. Sonak, JJ. Facts of the case in short (the judgment runs in to 78 pages): 1. Various petitions were clubbed together to decide following moot questions : a) Whether pregnancy can be terminated exceeding 20 weeks, i.e. the ceiling limit prescribed by Sec. 3(2) of MTP Act  and whether high Court has right to pass such order ? b) If permission is so granted, then what should be the procedure and what safeguards to be taken ? c) What is the legal status of the child born alive despite attempts   at   medical   termination   of   pregnancy   ­   the procedure   to   be   followed   in   such   cases   –   and   the responsibility of the State in such matte...

Hon. Supreme Court saddled Rs.10 lakhs fine with a clear message that, "Doctors, be responsive and diligent equally with all the patients.

Hon. Supreme Court saddled Rs.10 lakhs fine with a clear message that, "Doctors, be responsive and diligent equally with all the patients. Adv. Rohit Erande. © Case Details  Shoda Devi V/s. DDU/Ripon Hospital Shimla & ors. Civil Appeal No.2557/2019,  Decided on 07/03/2019 CORAM : Hon. ABHAY MANOHAR SAPRE J. & Hon. DINESH MAHESHWARI J. Judgment Link : https://www.sci.gov.in/supremecourt/2018/30932/30932_2018_Judgement_07-Mar-2019.pdf Facts in short : 1. The Appellant  with poor and Village background, knocked the doors of Hon. Supreme Court against the Order of Consumer Forums.  2. The Appellant was having menstrual problems, abdominal pains and approached the Respondent Deen Dayal Upadhyay (DDU) Hospital. She was diagnosed with fibroid and endometrial hyperplasia, at last was advised to undergo minor operation viz., Fractional Curettage (D & C). 3. During the operation, she was given intravenous injections direct...

Hon. Supreme Court fines Rs.40 lakhs(Hospital) & Rs.10 lakhs(Doctor) for not following Post.Op. Care.

Improper Post Operative care after Angioplasty  resulting into death of a patient, Hon. Supreme Court imposed  Rs.40 lakhs on the Hospital and Rs.10 lakhs on the  Treating Doctor ...  Sheela Jitna Naik Gaunekar V/s. Apollo Hospitals, Chennai. C.A. no. 3625/2005, decided on 05-10-2016, reported in I (2017) CPJ 1 (SC) Facts in short.. 1. The Widow -  Complainant filed the complaint for Rs.70 lakhs against the Hospital on account of sudden death of her husband who underwent  Angioplasty. 2.. It was alleged that there was no proper post-op care taken by the Hospital. 3. Both the parties lead extensive evidence in lower forum and the lower forums after perusing the evidence and more particularly cross exmination of Dr. Mathews came to the conclusion that there was Negligence in post-op treatment, after Angioplasty, which resulted in to death of the Patient & awarded Rs. 2 lakhs plus interest @6% p.a.  Both the parties approached ...

One judgment but "manifold Reliefs" to Doctors by Hon. Supreme Court. "No assurance of full recovery can be given", "Wrong diagnosis is not a negligence" "Its the prerogative of Doctors to decide line of treatment" and few more...

A recent Judgement of Hon. Apex Court may be referred to oasis for Doctors in these days. Their Lordships Observed, "We have sympathy for the appellant (who lost his beloved wife) , but sympathy cannot translate into a legal remedy" Case Details : Vinod Jain V/s. Santokba Durlabhji Memorial Hospital & ors. (2020) 1 SCC (civ.) 256 = (2019) 12 SCC 229. Civil Appeal No.2024/2019, decided on 25/02/2019 Coram : Hon. Sanjay Kisan Kaul and L. Nageswara Rao) Link : https://www.supremecourtofindia.nic.in/supremecourt/2017/34426/34426_2017_Judgement_25-Feb-2019.pdf Facts in short : The Appellant after consulting various Doctors and with his Doctor Son, settled in USA, decided to file the case against Doctors and Hospital. 1. The Appellant , who lost his beloved wife, case for Medical Negligence in Rajasthan State Forum against the Respondent. The State Forum allowed the Compliant, however the National Forum reversed the said Judgment and hence the Ap...