NCDRC Comes to the Rescue of Doctors – An Important Judgment Reaffirms That Every Unfortunate Medical Outcome Is Not Negligence - Adv. Rohit Erande ©
NCDRC Comes to the Rescue of Doctors – An Important Judgment Reaffirms That Every Unfortunate Medical Outcome Is Not Negligence
Case Details :
Judgment Link : https://indiankanoon.org/doc/186698613/
Facts of the case in short :
1. The case concerned a 54-year-old patient, Mr. Dhananjay Shankar Dhawde, who was admitted to Guntur City Hospital on 24 April 2012 with complaints of breathing difficulty, dyspepsia and constipation.
2. The patient was examined by a general physician and subsequently referred to a consultant cardiologist. Following clinical examination and investigations, the doctors advised further investigations, including a chest X-ray and CT scan, to ascertain the underlying cause of his symptoms.
3. The patient was discharged on 26 April 2012, with his vital parameters recorded as stable. He resumed his professional duties the following day. Unfortunately, he developed breathlessness on 28 April and died on 29 April 2012 while travelling at Rajahmundry.
4. His family alleged that the doctors had failed to diagnose an underlying cardiac condition and that this failure resulted in his death. The Andhra Pradesh State Consumer Commission accepted the allegations and directed the hospital and doctors to pay approximately Rs.38.25 lakhs with interest @ 9%. p.a.
Aggrieved by this order, the hospital and doctors approached the NCDRC.
Held :
The NCDRC carefully examined the medical records, clinical findings, expert opinion and circumstances surrounding the treatment and it was held that :.
The patient was examined by qualified medical professionals, including a consultant cardiologist.
Further investigations were advised to ascertain the precise cause of the patient's symptoms.
The patient's vital parameters were within normal limits at the time of discharge.
The patient had resumed his professional duties after discharge.
The patient did not return to the treating doctors for further evaluation after discharge.
There was no post-mortem report or independent medical evidence establishing the actual cause of death.
Expert Opinion - An important consideration was the independent expert opinion obtained from Dr. Y.V. Subba Reddy, Professor and Head of the Department of Cardiology, Osmania General Hospital, Hyderabad. The expert supported the diagnostic approach adopted by the treating cardiologist.
The NCDRC held that the State Commission had incorrectly discarded this expert opinion and had drawn an adverse inference against the doctors without sufficient justification.
The Commission ultimately concluded that the treatment and evaluation undertaken by the doctors were consistent with acceptable medical standards and that professional negligence had not been established. Accordingly, it set aside the State Commission's order and allowed the doctors' appeal.
The judgment is particularly significant because the NCDRC relied upon established principles laid down by the hon'ble Supreme Court.
1. Bolam Test
In Bolam v. Friern Hospital Management Committee, (1957) 2 All ER 118, the principle was established that a medical practitioner is not negligent if the treatment adopted is in accordance with a practice accepted as proper by a responsible body of medical professionals skilled in that particular field.
A doctor is not required to possess the highest degree of expertise; the law requires the exercise of reasonable professional skill and competence.
2. Jacob Mathew v. State of Punjab
(2005) 6 SCC 1
The Supreme Court explained that a medical professional can be held liable when either:
The doctor did not possess the requisite skill which he claimed to possess; or
The doctor failed to exercise reasonable competence in exercising the skill which he possessed.
A mere error of judgment, accident or difference of medical opinion does not automatically establish negligence.
3. Kusum Sharma v. Batra Hospital
*(2010) 3 SCC 480
The Supreme Court laid down important guidelines for determining medical negligence. It emphasised that doctors should not be subjected to unnecessary harassment and that negligence must be established by applying the standard of a reasonably competent medical practitioner. The NCDRC reiterated these principles in the present case.
There are several important takeaways for the Medicos from this decision:
1. No guarantee of successful treatment: Medical science involves uncertainty. An adverse outcome, including death, cannot by itself establish negligence.
2. Importance of expert evidence: An independent expert opinion from a qualified specialist can play a crucial role in determining whether the treatment was consistent with accepted medical practice.
3. Clinical judgment deserves respect: Doctors must be permitted to exercise their professional judgment in choosing an appropriate diagnostic or therapeutic approach. The mere availability of another course of treatment does not make the chosen course negligent.
4. Burden of proof: The complainant must establish the allegations of negligence through credible evidence. Mere allegations, assumptions or retrospective conclusions cannot substitute for proof.
5. Subsequent complications: A doctor cannot automatically be held responsible for a complication developing after discharge, particularly where the patient was clinically stable and there is no evidence establishing a breach of the applicable standard of care.
However, it should not be interpreted as giving doctors blanket immunity. Every case must be examined on its own facts, medical records, clinical circumstances and expert evidence. the maintenance of medical records also has no alternativve. Hospitals should establish appropriate systems for maintaining medical records and communicating pending investigation reports.
The larger message is that medical professionals should be accountable for genuine negligence, but they should not be made legally responsible for every complication, every unsuccessful treatment or every unfortunate death.
Adv. Rohit Erande ©
Comments
Post a Comment