Posts

A case of Rs.80 lakhs dismissed which alleged that Sedatives caused Cardiac arrest to alcoholic patient..

" The Complaint for Rs.80 lakhs alleging that Sedatives should not have been given to Alcoholic Patient as it caused cardiac arrest and complications, was dismissed " http://cms.nic.in/ncdrcusersWeb/GetPdf.do… The State Commission of Maharashtra, in the case of Smt.Rohini H. Merchant & ors. V/s. Sir H.N.Reliance Foundation Hospital & anr. has dealt with important factors. Factual Matrix in short : 1. The deceased patient - husband of Complainant No.1 Mr.Harendra J.Merchant was a Captain in Navy. It was contdned that he gave up his habitual consumption of liquor 25 years back. 2.But in the year 2005, when he was sailing near Andaman and Nicobar Islands, after seeing the hundreds of people dying to the Tsunami, he was psychologically and mentally disturbed and signed off the ship in February 2005 and due to trauma, he again started consuming alcohol after a long gap. 3.That, to treat the patient for proper detoxification, he was admitted on or ...

Doctors, No need to have Shop Act License... 3rd Judgment on this point...

Doctors, No need to have Shop Act License... 3rd Judgment on this point... The Division Bench of Hon. Bombay High Court (Nagpur Bench) in its comparatively recent judgment dated 21st October, 2016 has reiterated the earlier views in the case of Indian Medical Association V/s. State of Maharashtra & ors. (Writ Petition No. 4579/2005 ) 1. This is the 3rd Judgment on this Point which has relied upon 2 consecutive reported Judgments in the last year of Division Bench of Hon’ble Bombay High Court in the Case of Dr. Kavita Pravin Tilwani V/s. State of Maharashtra (2015(2) Mh.L.J. 271, Cri. W.P. No.1731 of 2002) and Dr. Shubhada Motwani V/s. State of Maharashtra (2015 (2) Mh.L.J. 408) wherein it has been held in clear and in equivocal words that Doctors do not fall within the Definition of “Commercial Establishment” under the provisions of Bombay Shops and Establishment Act, 1948 (said Act) and the amendment introduced in 1977 by which the Government included Medical Practitioners i...

Doctors, Why a Consent should be"Informed" ?

"Informed Consent" in Medical Treatment is of Utmost Importance,  !! Many times Docs do not pay importance to this fundamental aspect. To avoid further complications of Medcio-Legal cases, every Dr. should follow the Principles relating to consent as envisaged by Hon. Apex court of India in the case of Ms. Samira Kohli V/s Prabha manchanda (2008) 2 SCC 1. : You may see this link :http://judis.nic.in/supremecourt/imgs1.aspx?filename=30116 (i) A doctor has to seek and secure the consent of the patient before commencing a ’treatment’ (the term ’treatment’ includes surgery also). The consent so obtained should be real and valid, which means that : the patient should have the capacity and competence to consent; his consent should be voluntary; and his consent should be on the basis of adequate information concerning the nature of the treatment procedure, so that he knows what is consenting to. (ii)  The ’adequate information’ to be furnished by the doctor (or a membe...

"Condom is not the Medicine and hence fixation of the ceiling price for condoms is impermissible in Law !!!"

"Condom is not the Medicine and hence fixation of the ceiling price for condoms is impermissible in Law !!!" - Hon'ble Madras High Court, adopted the decision of Hon'ble Delhi High Court !! One never knows as to what kind of problems may come up before Courts ? The Delhi High Court was dealing with the core question of law as to Whether fixation of ceiling price under the provisions of the Drugs (Prices Control) Order (DPCO), 2013 for male contraceptives (condoms) is in conformity with the powers vested under the Essential Commodities Act, 1955 read with the Drugs and Cosmetics Act, 1940 in the case of RECKITT BENCKISER (INDIA) LTD. V/s. UNION OF INDIA AND ANR ( see the Judgment http://lobis.nic.in/ddir/dhc/GRO/judgement/10-07-2015/GRO10072015CW77052013.pdf ). The Petitioner contended that the prices of condoms were not controlled previously, however by order dated However, by order dated 05.11.2013, the National Pharmaceutical Pricing Authority, Department of ...

"A Dentist ordered to pay Rs.35,000/- for extracting wrong tooth, but the unwanted remarks about the competency of Doctor were expunged"

" A Dentist ordered to pay Rs.35,000/- for extracting wrong tooth, but  the unwanted remarks about the competency of Doctor were expunged"  http://cms.nic.in/ncdrcusersWeb/GetJudgement.do?method=GetJudgement&caseidin=6%2F0%2FA%2F22%2F2017&dtofhearing=2017-04-24 In an interesting case, the Chandigarh State Commission while delivering judgment in case of Tanvir Malik V/s.  Dr. Harvansh Singh Judge Institute of Dental Sciences and Hospital Chandigarh, upheld the order of the District Forum, but with some important modifications. Facts in short : 1. The Appellant - complainant on 6.9.2015 went to Opponent institute for treatment of his braces. His tooth no. 28 and 38 were to be removed. It's the case of the Appellant that tooth No.38 was correctly extracted, but instead of tooth No.28, the Doctor  extracted tooth No.27 2. Hence the Compliant for Medical Negligence was filed. 3. It was proved that the wrong tooth was removed, hence the District forum all...

When a Doctor received Rs.19 lakhs compensation from another Doctor..

"A Gynaecologist to receive Rs.19 lakhs for faulty eye surgery from an Ophthalmologist" http://cms.nic.in/ncdrcusersWeb/GetJudgement.do… The Delhi State Consumer Commission was dealing with the case, where both the parties were Doctors.. Case Details Dr. (Mrs.) Prakash Sharma V/s. Dr. Sharad Lakhotia & anr. CC No. 283/2001, decided on 27/04/2017. Facts in short : 1.The Complainant, a Senior gynecologist from Delhi approached (November - 1998) the Respondent Ophthalmologist for vision problem in her left eye. After investigation, the complainant was advised to undergo cataract surgery & also for implantation of Intra-Ocular-Lens (IOL) The complainant was assured that the IOL implantation was 100% safe and a latest technique. 2. After the surgery, which was successful according to the treating Doctor, Complainant however immediately told the Dr. that she had a blurred vision and could not see with the left eye. After testing on some machines, i...

"4 days delay in taking remedial steps costed Rs. 12 lakhs to the Gynaec, Anesthetist and the Hospital "

"4 days delay in taking remedial steps proved to be harmful to the patient and it jointly costed Rs. 12 lakhs to the Gynaec, Anesthetist and the Hospital " Case Details : DR. SUTAPA DASGUPT & ANR, KOLKATA V/s. TAPAN KAR & ANR. REVISION PETITION NO. 315 OF 2016, decided on 18 May 2017 http://cms.nic.in/ncdrcusersWeb/GetJudgement.do?method=GetJudgement&caseidin=0%2F0%2FRP%2F315%2F2016&dtofhearing=2017-05-18 Facts in short. 1.The wife of the Complainant i.e.Ms. Gopa Kar (patient) was admitted for delivery of baby by C-Section at Zenith Super Specialty Hospital on 15th December, 2010. 2.On the same day she was administered anesthesia by the Petitioner No.1 Doctor in her spinal cord and thereafter caesarean section surgery was conducted and she delivered a male child. 3. But soon after  regaining consciousness after delivery the patient  had complaint that her lower limbs were paralyzed and there was no sensation before or at the time of passing urine ...